Robert Dole and George J. Mitchell

The bill then beingness offered by Senator Mitchell was the occasion for this conceive, and Mitchell sates in his speech that he welcomes the debate and that he believes his bill is a good starting acme for the discussion. Inherent in both speeches is the subtext that this is an issue of import to the voter and that legislators had not addressed it as they should have in the past.

The difficulty itself has been well documented. In the remnant 15 years, the subprogram of uninsurable Americans has grown, and nigh estimates in 1991 place the number lacking existence or private coverage at between 31 and 36 million. According to the 1987 National Medical Expenditure Survey, both(prenominal) 47.8 million people lacked insurance for altogether or deduct of 1987, and the U.S. Bureau of the Census found that from the first bum of 1986 to the last quarter of 1988, 63.6 million people lacked coverage for at to the lowest degree one and only(a) month and 31.5 million lacked it in the last(a) quarter of 1988. In terms of age, those between 19 and 24 years of age are the most likely to be uninsured, and 20.3 share of this group were uninsured for entirely of 1987 and another 18.2 percent for incite of the year. Children under 18 years of age were the next most likely to be uninsured so that one in four were uninsured either all or discussion section of the year. Of those aged 25 to 54 years, 19.8 percent were uninsured all or p

In the final analysis, it was the pogey point of view that prevailed as no health care legislation was passed. Dole does not make a case for his plan here, and he did not make one to Congress after that. Indeed, the case he makes here--that it is better to sojourn and consider all options before choosing--is what Congress eventually hold to do. This is also why the future of the debate is so uncertain--listening to these dickens speeches tells us what was defeated, but it does not make clear what marriage proposal was being offered by the opposition and thus what proposal they capability make in the future. Dole affirms Republican commitment, but all his passion was in countering the Democratic proposal and not in offering his own. This undercuts his ability to convey commitment to his listeners.

Dole's speech is often whiles more(prenominal) conversational than was Mitchell's, sounding often as it were more offthe-cuff than written. This adds to the sense that this is a response to the earlier speech, as if Dole had just heard the other speech and was like a shot answering what he has heard. He makes use of a number of rhetorical devices to point up distinctions and to undercut whatever weather Mitchell may have gathered by his earlier speech. Dole does this primarily with understatement and irony, as when he states:

The two speeches under discussion were delivered to the same auditory sense on the same day, as noted. That audience consisted of the members of the United States Senate who were present for the health care debate. By the time of these speeches, the issue had been much discussed in the news media and by mixed legislators in meetings and before the media. The issue had been aired in townspeople meetings held by President Clinton. Hillary Clinton had been the head of a task labour charged with analyzing the health care system and with coming up with a proposal, and elements in the Clinton proposal had been leaked over a close of time so that the issue was kept alive. Hillary Clinton had a
Order your essay at Orderessay and get a 100% original and high-quality custom paper within the required time frame.